Has Bosch abandoned laser-based LIDAR for self-driving cars due to better alternatives from competitors?
09/01/2023 •
Yes, Bosch has considered alternatives to laser-based LIDAR for self-driving cars. — The majority of comments suggest a divide in opinions with many supporting LIDAR for its safety and accuracy benefits, while others view camera-based systems as adequate. However, the presence of discussions around better alternatives and the criticism towards some companies skipping LIDAR indicates a trend towards alternative technologies.
Stats
| 86% | 86 | |
| 12% | 12 | Hacker News |
| 2% | 2 | Bluesky |
| 49% | Negative |
| 30% | Neutral |
| 21% | Positive |
| 65% | 😃 Joy |
| 19% | 😡 Anger |
| 16% | 😱 Fear |
| 0% | 😢 Sadness |
| 0% | 🥰 Love |
| 0% | 😯 Surprise |
😃
😡
😱
Story
- LIDAR has issues with dark surfaces and may not reflect enough light back, potentially affecting its performance on people of color, but newer generation LIDAR systems might improve this.
- Elon Musk and his team at Tesla believe that LIDAR is obsolete because self-driving is primarily a vision problem, but others argue that Tesla's camera-only approach may not be the best solution due to safety concerns.
- Some comments emphasize that LIDAR, when combined with computer vision, provides faster computation times and more accurate depth perception compared to cameras alone.
- There's a belief that Tesla's reliance on camera-only technology could be compromising safety and that their avoidance of LIDAR might have slowed their progress in self-driving tech.
- Several comments criticize companies operating without LIDAR, stressing its importance for safe autonomous driving.
- There's confidence in the potential advances of RADAR and LIDAR technology, suggesting German companies can still be involved in future automotive matters despite possibly abandoning laser-based LIDAR.
- Some comments propose Clarity's camera system may be superior in depth perception when compared to LIDAR.
- LIDAR has specific limitations like not functioning optimally in fog or snow and can interfere with other LIDAR-equipped cars at night.
- A combination of LIDAR and computer vision is seen by some as beneficial for self-driving systems, offering accurate depth perception and faster computation times.